文章摘要
评绿蓝悖论的消除主义方案——与陈晓平教授商榷
On the Eliminative Strategy to the Grue Paradox: A Discussion with Professor Chen Xiaoping
  
DOI:
中文关键词: 绿蓝悖论  消除主义  确证  观察
英文关键词: Grue paradox  the eliminative strategy  confirm  observation
基金项目:
作者单位
邓桂芳,徐敏 华中科技大学 哲学系湖北 武汉 430074 
摘要点击次数: 1199
全文下载次数: 1695
中文摘要:
      针对绿蓝悖论,西方学界有代表性的解悖方案主要包括语言主义方案、贝叶斯主义方案和证伪主义方案。我国学者陈晓平教授独立地提出不属于三种方案的消除主义方案。根据该方案,绿蓝悖论所涉论证中某个牵涉证据陈述的前提并不成立。我们从两个方面提出批评意见,认为该方案并不是一种令人满意的解悖方案。
英文摘要:
      There are mainly three different approaches to the Grue paradox, i.e. the Linguistic Approach, the Bayesian Approach, and the Falsificationistic Approach. Professor Chen Xiaoping proposes a different strategy, that is, the Eliminative Strategy, to solve the Grue paradox. According to this strategy, in the corresponding argument one premise concerning evidence statements is not true. We make two criticisms to this strategy. Our conclusion is that the Eliminative Strategy does not constitute a satisfactory solution to the Grue paradox.
查看全文   查看/发表评论  下载PDF阅读器
关闭